Table 2 The workflow data from the included studies
No | Study | race | Exosomes Source | Exosome Isolation | Biomarker Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Abbastabar, M. [23] | Caucasian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
2 | Bian, B. [24] | Asian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
3 | Chen, C. [25] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
4 | El-Shal,A.S. [26] | Caucasian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
5 | Güllü Amuran,G. [27] | Caucasian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
6 | Huang,H. [28] | Asian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
7 | Lee,J.S. [29] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation/Exosome Isolation Kit | ELISA |
8 | Lin,H [30] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
9 | Liu,C. [31] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
10 | Matsuzaki,K. [32] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | Unclear |
11 | Qiu,T. [33] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
12 | Sarfi,M. [34] | Caucasian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
13 | Wen,J. [35] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
14 | Xu,Y. [36] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
15 | Yazarlou,F. [37] | Caucasian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
16 | De Long,J. [38] | Caucasian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
17 | Gao,Y. [39] | Asian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
18 | Zhan,Y. [40] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
19 | Wang X [41] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |
20 | Murakami T [42] | Asian | urine | Exosome Isolation Kit | qRT-PCR |
21 | Yang FK [43] | Asian | urine | Ultracentrifugation | qRT-PCR |